An Uber customer asked a Manhattan federal judge to overturn an arbitration win for the company in a price-fixing case, arguing that the arbitrator only ruled in Uber’s favour because he was scared.
- Uber customer asked a Manhattan judge to overturn an arbitration win for the company in a price-fixing case
- Money collected from ride hailing trips make up the bulk of the company’s revenue
- The lawsuit sought a nationwide ban against surge pricing
Spencer Meyer initiated the high-profile 2015 antitrust lawsuit alleging that Uber Technologies engaged in an illegal conspiracy with its drivers to coordinate high “surge pricing” fares during periods of heavy demand by agreeing to charge prices set by an algorithm in the Uber ride-hailing app.
Uber takes a cut from drivers’ earnings, and ride-hailing trips in North America make up the bulk of the company’s revenue. The lawsuit sought a nationwide ban against surge pricing.
Uber argues its drivers are independent contractors and that its app is merely a technology platform connecting drivers with riders. Uber declined to comment on the court filing.
The company has previously said it believed the law was on its side, pointing to the fact that no antitrust agency has raised issues.
The lawsuit went through several courts before it was sent into arbitration in 2019 in accordance with Uber’s terms of service that mandate arbitration behind closed doors for most lawsuits.
The appointed arbitrator, attorney Les Weinstein, on the 22nd of February ruled in Uber’s favour and dismissed the lawsuit, but according to Friday’s filings he did so out of “evident partiality.”
A transcript excerpt of the arbitration, attached to the filing, cited him saying: “I must say I act out of fear. My fear is if I ruled Uber illegal, I would need security. I wouldn’t be able to walk the streets at night. People would be after me.”
Weinstein also questioned whether he had the legal power to ban surge pricing nationwide. He did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Uber has a week to respond to the filing in court.
The team at Platform Executive hope you have enjoyed the ‘Uber customer claims company won price-fixing suit because arbitrator was scared‘ article. Automatic translation from English to a growing list of languages via Google AI Cloud Translation. Initial reporting via our official content partners at Thomson Reuters. Reporting by Tina Bellon in New York. Editing by Aurora Ellis.