Twitch will ban users for ‘severe misconduct’ that occurs away from the platform

Platform News: Twitch app

Twitch will ban users for offenses such as hate-group membership or credible threats of mass violence that occur entirely away from the site, in a new approach to moderating the platform, the company has said.

The Amazon-owned platform, which is popular among video gamers, said under its new rules it would take enforcement actions against offline offenses that posed a “substantial safety risk” to its community.

It said examples of this “severe misconduct” include terrorist activities, child sexual exploitation, violent extremism, credible threats of mass violence, carrying out or deliberately acting as an accomplice to sexual assault and threatening Twitch or its staff.

“Taking action against misconduct that occurs entirely off our service is a novel approach for both Twitch and the industry at large, but it’s one we believe – and hear from you – is crucial to get right,” the company said in a blog post.

Major social media companies Facebook and Twitter largely focus their rules and enforcement actions on content and activity on the actual services, with exceptions for certain individuals or organizations they have designated as dangerous or violent.

Related article:
US senator wants to ban 'Big Tech' from buying anything ever again

Twitch previously took into account off-service behaviours related to incidents on the site, such as harassment on other social media platforms. It said it had also historically taken action against serious misconduct away from its service, such as when it suspended the account of  President Trump after a crowd stormed the US Capitol building in January, Twitch said it did not have a large-scale approach in the past.

The company said users will be able to report such behaviours but it may also investigate cases proactively, for instance if there is a verified news report that a user has been arrested.

Twitch said it would rely more heavily on law enforcement in “off-service” cases and is partnering with an investigative law firm to support its internal team. It declined to name the firm.

The new standards will apply even if the target of the offline behaviours is not a Twitch user or if the perpetrator was not a user when they committed the acts. Perpetrators would also be banned from registering a Twitch account, it said.

Twitch said it would take action only when there was evidence, such as screen shots, videos of off-Twitch behaviour or police filings, verified by its internal team or third-party investigators. Users who submit a large amount of frivolous reports will face suspension.

Related article:
Spotify's Joe Rogan saga spotlights podcast moderation challenges

The company said in cases where the behaviour happened in the distant past, users had gone through rehabilitation such as time in a correctional facility, and they no longer presented a danger to the community, it might not take action or might reinstate users on appeal.

It said it would share updates with the involved parties but would not share public updates about actions under this policy.

Comment: This is a slippery slope and a worrying development for tech platforms. The move likely encourages cyber-stalking of users by activists. Moreover, as the company is owned by a company with the reach and power of Amazon, it has the potential to impact many lives.

Obvious question: Is this the forerunner of a group-wide policy at Amazon?

In my opinion, it certainly sounds like a forerunner to a social credit scoring system, as seen in China.

The team at Platform Executive hope you have enjoyed the ‘Twitch will ban users for ‘severe misconduct’ that occurs away from the platform‘ article. Translation from English to a growing list of other languages via Google Cloud Translation. Initial reporting via our official content partners at Thomson Reuters. Reporting by Elizabeth Culliford in New York. Editing by Kenneth Li and Matthew Lewis. Comment by Rob Phillips.

Related article:
Swedish start-up Epidemic Sound tunes into demand for original music

Stay on top of all the latest developments across the platform economy and gain access to our problem-solving tools, proprietary databases and content sets by becoming a member of our community. For a limited time, subscription plans start from just $16 per month.

Share this Article